Tuesday, October 5, 2010

Interesting Commentary on I Corinthians 14:26-33

As I was looking through some of my books today, I happened upon William Barclay's commentary on I Corinthians (The Letter to the Corinthians, Westminster Press, 1975). I don't even know how this book ended up in my possession, but rather than ponder that, I decided to see what Barclay says about I Corinthians 14. In particular, I was curious about what he thinks about early church gatherings (read I Cor. 14:26-33 here).

Among other things, Barclay writes this on page 134,

"There was obviously a flexibility about the order of service in the early Church. Everything was informal enough to allow any man who felt that he had a message to give to give it. It may well be that we set far too much store on dignity and order nowadays, and have become the slaves of orders of service. The really notable thing about an early Church service must have been that almost everyone came feeling that he had both the privilege and the obligation of contributing something to it. A man did not come with the sole intention of being a passive listener; he came not only to receive but to give. Obviously this had its dangers, for it is clear that in Corinth there were those who were too fond of the sound of their own voices; but nonetheless the Church must have been in those days much more the real possession of the ordinary Christian. It may well be that the Church lost something when she delegated so much to the professional ministry and left so little to the ordinary Church member."

While I don't agree with all of Barclay's terminology ("service," "member"), I do appreciate his observations on what early church gatherings looked like. In particular, Barclay points out the flexibility, informality, and participatory nature of church meetings. Notice that Barclay writes of the gatherings that each man had "both the privilege and the obligation of contributing something to it."

What impact should the above information have on our church meetings today? What obligations do we as individuals have to bring something to our gatherings? Should we learn from the early church, or do we have freedom to do what we want to do?

2 comments:

Aussie John said...

Eric,

I would add one more question:

"What impact should the above information have on our church leaders of today?"

They would be trembling in their shoes!

"What impact should the above information have on our church meetings today?"

The meetings would become more Scriptural, and, as a consequence, of value to the Body, and more glorifying to God.

"What obligations do we as individuals have to bring something to our gatherings?"

Every obligation to bring something of the "one anothers" of Scripture, such as Paul instructed, "What, then, does this mean, brothers? When you gather, everyone has a psalm, teaching, revelation, tongue, or interpretation. Everything must be done for upbuilding."

" (A)Should we learn from the early church, or (B)do we have freedom to do what we want to do?"

(A) Absolutely!

(B) We have been doing that since the Reformation, and look where it has got us!

Eric said...

John,

I agree that the one-anothers are the key. We all need to grow from edifying one another. Clearly, this means that all will actively participate.